Small is beautiful: Viewing hydrogen atoms with neutron protein crystallography

Creating 3D visualizations of hydrogen atoms in proteins is especially challenging, often requiring their locations to be inferred from those of nearby carbon, nitrogen, oxygen or sulfur atoms stored in protein structure databases. These locations are based on atomic positions…

Creating 3D visualizations of hydrogen atoms in proteins is especially challenging, often requiring their locations to be inferred from those of nearby carbon, nitrogen, oxygen or sulfur atoms stored in protein structure databases. These locations are based on atomic positions in databases of previously solved structures, general chemical knowledge, quantum mechanical calculations, or potential hydrogen bonding interactions. While X-ray crystallography can pinpoint hydrogen atom locations at ultrahigh resolution, in practice only a few such positions are experimentally determined. Recently, however, scientists at the University of Toledo, Los Alamos National Laboratory and Oak Ridge National Laboratory used neutron crystallography – a technique that even at lower resolutions can locate individual hydrogen atoms by leveraging scattering properties of the hydrogen isotope deuterium.

Research Professor Julian C.-H. Chen discussed the group’s research with, first summarizing the main challenges they faced in overcoming the limitations of only X-ray crystallography, visualizing hydrogen atoms a three-dimensional context, determining protonation states of active site residues in enzymes, and establishing the identities and orientation of solvent molecules. “The strength of neutron crystallography lies in its ability to locate hydrogen atoms in macromolecular structures. Hydrogen accounts for one-half of the atoms in any given protein, and help perform all sorts of tasks, from hydrogen bonding to catalysis,” Chen explains. “For X-ray crystallography, locating hydrogen atoms is especially difficult as they possess just one electron, and X-rays are weakly scattered by hydrogen atoms compared to other elements in proteins such as carbon, oxygen, nitrogen, and sulfur.”
Furthermore, hydrogen atoms in protein structures can be quite mobile. “You’re lucky to be able to see them even in the highest resolution structures,” Chen continues. “Neutrons, on the other hand, have the nifty property that deuterium, which can be introduced into reactive sites on the protein through hydrogen/deuterium exchange, scatters neutrons so they are easily located and readily visible in nuclear density maps, even at moderate resolution. So this makes it relatively straightforward to determine protonation states of residues. Similarly, for solvent molecules, D2O, or heavy water, can be introduced into the crystal – and these molecules have an easily identifiable boomerang shape in the nuclear density maps, which makes it possible to orient them.”
On addressing these challenges, Chen adds, “We reasoned that if we had the combination of ultrahigh resolution and neutron diffraction data on hydrogen/deuterium-exchanged crystals, we should be able to describe how individual deuterium atoms vibrate – and not only that, but also describe their anisotropic vibrational motion.” (An anisotropic material exhibits different values of a property in different crystallographic directions.) “So that’s exactly what we did for a number of selected deuterium atoms within crambin – a protein that forms the best-ordered macromolecular crystals known. We surmised that crambin crystals would diffract neutrons to ultra-high resolution as well.”
As Chen points out, crambin is a small protein with a limited number of deuterium atoms. “Especially with the new neutron crystallography instruments under construction or being commissioned, new datasets of similar or higher resolution should be possible with crambin as well as other proteins. We’re of course staying updated on these developments.” Chen adds that some of their findings pertaining to hydrogen/deuterium exchange can also be addressed by other physical methods.
Chen also comments on their key findings provide the ability to inventory all hydrogen bonding interactions within the protein and ascertain the categories and suggest strengths of hydrogen bonds in the system; demonstrate the power of ultrahigh resolution neutron diffraction to resolve ambiguous hydrogen bonding networks; and reveal unconventional structural features and interatomic interactions. “You generally only see the oxygen of the water in X-ray structures, keep in mind that the two hydrogens scatter X-rays weakly and are generally invisible.” This means that the hydrogen bonding networks can be ambiguous. “But with neutrons,” Chen continues, “since you get strong scattering from the deuteriums of the D2O, you can orient the hydrogens and figure out the network of hydrogen bond donors and acceptors.”
Moreover, says Chen, the researchers also saw some instances of unusual hydrogen/deuterium exchange patterns. “One residue in particular appeared to have hydrogen/deuterium exchange on one of the hydrogens bonded to the alpha carbon. This could be evidence of C-H…O hydrogen bonds, which are rather elusive and difficult to observe experimentally although nearly 30 years of mostly computational work have been done on these hydrogen bonds.”
In terms of other research and downstream technology might benefit from your findings, Chen stresses that their study demonstrates what can be done with neutron crystallography. “I think that this, and future structures, will give the humble hydrogen atom its due,” Chen concludes. “This will hopefully work its way into computational algorithms that address protein-ligand and protein-drug interactions. This work may also lead in the long run to more accurate, higher quality macromolecular structures.”

More information: Direct observation of hydrogen atom dynamics and interactions by ultrahigh resolution neutron protein crystallography, PNAS September 4, 2012, doi:10.1073/pnas.1208341109Journal reference:

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences

Copyright 2012 All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed in whole or part without the express written permission of

view popular
send feedback to editors

5 /5 (5 votes)




5 /5 (5 votes)

more news

Related Stories

Jan 28, 2009
Structure of enzyme against chemical warfare agents determined

May 16, 2006
Study applies neutrons to study hydrogen transfer in biological systems

Jan 07, 2009
Heavy Pyridine Crystallizes Differently

Jun 24, 2011
In Brief: Unmasking elusive hydrogen

Relevant PhysicsForums posts

Mathematical description of Refractive index in crystal/glass
4 hours ago

I have read on a website that the refractive index of glass is related to the number of electrons it has per unit volume.

I don’t recall which website it was, but is it true? & if so what…

Question about strong force
5 hours ago
Reading about the strong force and the residual strong force I’m a bit confused about the interaction. Largely it keeps mentioning it the result of particle exchange and mentions that it has infinite…

about fermi levels in extrensic semiconductors.
Oct 12, 2012
Why does the Fermi level level drop with increase in temperature for a n type semiconductor.? What’s the basic idea behind Fermi level?
How does it get affected by temprature?

Can NPT simulate a thermal dissociation process?
Oct 11, 2012
e.g. CaCO3 goes to CaO+ CO2 when heated? Thanks.

Surface Reconstruction: RHEED/LEED
Oct 11, 2012
I’m having some trouble understanding surface reconstruction diffraction patterns. Please see Figure 2 on the third page of the attached document. An in-depth knowledge of the subject matter isn’t…

Full Width at Half Maximum (FWHM) Interpretation
Oct 11, 2012
Very commonly in thin film articles/journals, I find the full width at half maximum of X-ray rocking curves associated with the quality (order) of the surface. For example, if the same material is…

More from Physics Forums – Atomic, Solid State, Comp. Physics

More news stories

On the origin of life’s most crucial isotope

Since the Big Bang, the universe has been evolving. From the formations of simple protons and neutrons to the wide breadth of elements and molecules known today, it is ever growing in complexity and variety. And now, nuclear …

Physics / General Physics

22 hours ago |
4.5 / 5 (2) |

Is it real? Physicists propose method to determine if the universe is a simulation

(—A common theme of science fiction movies and books is the idea that we’re all living in a simulated universe—that nothing is actually real. This is no trivial pursuit: some of the greatest minds …

Physics / General Physics

Oct 12, 2012 |
4.1 / 5 (20) |

Physicists extend special relativity beyond the speed of light

(—Possibly the most well-known consequence of Einstein’s theory of special relativity is that nothing can travel faster than the speed of light, c. According to the mass-energy equivalence formul …

Physics / General Physics

Oct 08, 2012 |
4.8 / 5 (49) |

‘Superstructured’ solar cells achieve record efficiency of 10.9%

(—It may sound counterintuitive that replacing one of the most photosensitive solar cell materials with a material with less desirable photosensitive properties can improve the solar cell’s efficiency, …

Physics / Condensed Matter

Oct 11, 2012 |
5 / 5 (11) |

Quantam research will yield ‘super-computers’: Nobel winner

David Wineland, who won the Nobel Prize for work in quantum physics with Serge Haroche of France, said our limited computers will “eventually” give way to super-fast, revolutionary ones. …

Physics / Quantum Physics

Oct 10, 2012 |
4.5 / 5 (10) |

Bird flu debate: Should H5N1 experiments resume?

Virologists making mutated versions of the H5N1 bird flu halted their research in January after a U.S. government advisory panel suggested that their work, though well-intentioned, had the potential to endanger the public.

Medicine & Health / Medical research
52 minutes ago |
not rated yet |

Shuttle passes obstacle, heads toward LA museum

Slowly surmounting a key obstacle, the shuttle Endeavour maintained a heading Saturday through the streets of Los Angeles toward its retirement home at a museum.

Space & Earth / Space Exploration
48 minutes ago |
5 / 5 (1) |

Retailers large and small find advantages to mobile payments

The way we pay for things is changing. Those credit-card keypads yielding paper receipts are giving way to a new group of mobile payment devices that merchants say charge cheaper swipe fees, and are faster and easier to use.

Technology / Telecom
54 minutes ago |
not rated yet |

Soyuz rocket launches two Galileo satellites

A Soyuz rocket launched two Galileo satellites into orbit on Friday, marking a crucial step for Europe’s planned navigation system, operator Arianespace announced.

Space & Earth / Space Exploration
5 hours ago |
not rated yet |

Sponge-like graphene makes promising supercapacitor electrodes

(—While most of today’s electric vehicles rely on batteries to store energy, supercapacitors have enjoyed significant improvements that have made them serious competitors to batteries. Batteries …

Nanotechnology / Nanomaterials
23 hours ago |
4.3 / 5 (12) |

Dyson engineers labor toward hair-free turbine solution (w/ Video)

(—At such an innovation rich time of telepresence, 3-D printing, advanced cryptography, advanced medical imaging, and robotics, you need to wonder why in all this time we never got a break with …

Technology / Hi Tech & Innovation
16 hours ago |
4.8 / 5 (11) |