17 February 2012
UC DAVIS (US) —Using seawater to cool nuclear fuel was the best choice for post-tsunami Japan, but the method could be risky.
Alexandra Navrotsky, a professor at the University of California, Davis, says Japan’s choice to use seawater at the stricken Fukushima-Daiichi nuclear plant was probably the best action to take at the time.
But Navrotsky and others have since discovered a new way in which seawater can corrode nuclear fuel, forming uranium compounds that could potentially travel long distances, either in solution or as very small particles. The research team published its work in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
“This is a phenomenon that has not been considered before,” says Navrotsky, distinguished professor of ceramic, earth, and environmental materials chemistry. “We don’t know how much this will increase the rate of corrosion, but it is something that will have to be considered in future.”
Japan used seawater to avoid a much more serious accident at the Fukushima-Daiichi plant, and Navrotsky says, to her knowledge, there is no evidence of long-distance uranium contamination from the plant.
Uranium in nuclear fuel rods is in a chemical form that is “pretty insoluble” in water, Navrotsky said, unless the uranium is oxidized to uranium-VI—a process that can be facilitated when radiation converts water into peroxide, a powerful oxidizing agent.
Peter Burns, professor of civil engineering and geological sciences at the University of Notre Dame and a co-author of the paper, had previously made spherical uranium peroxide clusters, rather like carbon “buckyballs,” that can dissolve or exist as solids.
In the new paper, the researchers show that in the presence of alkali metal ions such as sodium—for example, in seawater—these clusters are stable enough to persist in solution or as small particles even when the oxidizing agent is removed.
In other words, these clusters could form on the surface of a fuel rod exposed to seawater and then be transported away, surviving in the environment for months or years before reverting to more common forms of uranium, without peroxide, and settling to the bottom of the ocean.
There is no data yet on how fast these uranium peroxide clusters will break down in the environment, Navrotsky says.
Navrotsky and Burns worked with co-authors at UC Davis, Sandia National Laboratory, and the University of Notre Dame.
The U.S. Department of Energy supported the project.